Amazon's BEST Deals on Select Maybelline New York — Updated Jan 13th, 2025

From mascaras that give your lashes wings to lipsticks that slay all day, this list has got you covered! Prepare to look so fabulous, even your makeup brushes will be like, "Damn, girl, where did you find these deals?" Let's add some serious sparkle to your makeup collection!

Everything you need to know about Amazon Subscribe & Save...

What is this subscription program?

Subscribe & Save is Amazon's subscription program where once a month you can get a box of items of your choice for up to an extra 15% off Amazon's already low prices. Save on time, money, hassle and gas while keeping your household stocked up!

Some benefits of using Subscribe & Save for Amazon Prime members include:

Discounts: You can save up to 15% on your subscribed items, and the more items you subscribe to, the higher the discount.
Convenience: You don't have to worry about running out of your frequently purchased items because they will be delivered to you automatically.
Flexibility: You can change or cancel your subscriptions at any time.
Free Shipping: Your subscribed items will be delivered to you with free shipping.
No commitment: You can skip a delivery or cancel your subscription at any time without penalty.

Can I cancel at any time?

Absolutely! Amazon will even send you an email up to 3 days before your order ships so you can cancel any renewing subscriptions if you'd like! A great tip is to select your subscription to ship every 6 months, giving you ample time to cancel.

How do I cancel my Amazon Subscribe & Save subscriptions?

Go to this page, select the item you want to cancel and click cancel subscription. We recommend choosing the option "this is too expensive" so it encourages Amazon to give us more low prices.

Will my Amazon subscription renew at the same price?

Unfortunately, no. As we feature many of Amazon's best Subscribe & Save deals, usually with one-time use coupons, any future deliveries will renew at the current price at the time of shipment, including any Subscribe & Save discounts. This is why many people choose to delete subscriptions after they have shipped. Setting your subscription to 6 months maximizes your time to cancel, especially if your ordering habits are price-based.

Why isn't my Subscribe & Save page showing the prices I agreed to pay?

To see the price you agreed to, click into your orders and find the specific Subscribe & Save item. The discounts should be listed in the invoice. Currently, discounts are not shown on the Subscribe & Save page. Rest assured, you will never be charged more than what you agree to for the first order, but future deliveries might cost more.

How do I move my Subscribe & Save order if I'll be on vacation?

To move your delivery date, go to the Subscribe & Save page and click 'Change delivery date.' You might even be able to move your delivery date up to receive your items faster! It's possible to receive more than one Subscribe & Save box per month. Reasons to move or skip a delivery include being fully stocked or away from home.

Is the Subscribe & Save discount the same for every item?

Actually, no. The Subscribe & Save discount varies. Check the discount box before checkout. With 5 or more items shipping in a month, you'll get a higher discount, typically 5%-20%. Fewer items will yield a lower discount, around 0%-5%.

Can I save money by ordering 4 more Subscribe & Save items?

Absolutely, there are situations where adding one more item can increase your total subscription discount, outweighing the cost of the 5th item, thus saving you money.